Ortobello's

Ortobello's

6401 Bay Pkwy, Brooklyn, NY 11204, United States

+1 718-236-9810

Italian restaurant
(524)
Share Your Experience

About This Place

Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn at 6401 Bay Parkway, Ortobello's is a charming Italian restaurant that invites you into a warm and authentic dining experience. From the moment you step inside, the cozy atmosphere and attentive, friendly service set the stage for a memorable meal. Though quaint and modest in appearance, Ortobello's offers a culinary journey that Italian food lovers will quickly fall in love with.

Their menu is a celebration of classic Italian flavors, expertly crafted with fresh ingredients and generous portions that truly satisfy. Start your meal with tantalizing appetizers such as the crispy, golden Fried Calamari or the rich, briny Baked Clams. The Mussels Marinara and Seafood Salad are each vibrant with fresh ocean flavors, perfectly balanced by zesty herbs and tangy tomato sauce.

For the main course, Ortobello's shines with beloved Italian staples like the Pollo Parmigiana served alongside al dente spaghetti, the indulgent Chicken Francese with its velvety lemon sauce, or the hearty Spaghetti Carbonara, rich with creamy egg and pancetta. Those seeking something extra special can indulge in their expertly prepared veal dishes—from the Veal Parmesan to the elegant Veal Sorrentino, featuring delicate eggplant, prosciutto, and melted mozzarella in a luscious marsala sauce. The Boneless Ribeye and Potato Croquettes offer a delicious departure for meat lovers craving something more robust.

Every dish is crafted with care and packed with flavor, from the subtle balsamic notes of the Veal Capricciosa to the satisfying crunch of Mozzarella Logs. Complement your meal with a glass of house red wine, perfectly pairing with the rich sauces and savory mains.

Don't forget to save room for dessert—whatever you choose, whether the homemade Ricotta Cheesecake, the silky Tiramisu, or the classic Italian Cheesecake, you’re in for a sweet, unforgettable finish that beautifully rounds out the meal.

Patrons often praise the restaurant’s authentic tastes, attentive service, and the inviting vibe that makes Ortobello's feel like a beloved neighborhood gem. Several diners have noted the importance of making reservations ahead of time, as the intimate space fills quickly—a testament to the quality and loyalty this spot inspires.

Whether you’re gathering with family, enjoying a quiet dinner with a loved one, or catching up with friends, Ortobello's offers a delectable slice of Italy in Brooklyn, wrapped in genuine hospitality and rich, heartwarming flavors that linger long after the last bite.

Service options
Delivery Takeaway Dine-in
Highlights
Fast service Great coffee Great wine list Serves local specialty
Popular for
Lunch Dinner Solo dining
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Offerings
Alcohol Beer Coffee Comfort food Wine
Dining options
Lunch Dinner Catering Dessert Table service
Amenities
Toilet
Atmosphere
Casual Cosy
Crowd
Family friendly Groups Locals Tourists
Planning
Dinner reservations recommended Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards Debit cards Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
Parking
Free of charge street parking Paid street parking

Opening Hours

  • Monday
    Closed
  • Tuesday
    04:30 PM - 10:00 PM
  • Wednesday
    04:30 PM - 10:00 PM
  • Thursday
    04:30 PM - 10:00 PM
  • Friday
    04:30 PM - 10:00 PM
  • Saturday
    04:30 PM - 10:00 PM
  • Sunday
    03:30 PM - 09:00 PM

Map & Directions

Visitor Reviews

  • Ronald Loria
    2 month ago

    The portions are very generous, and well seasoned. The seafood salad was great. Wife had penne a la vodka with shrimps and fell in love, I had chicken Parmesan with ziti it was very good. The service is very grinding l grinding friendly and efficient. Please make reservations.

  • J B C
    2 month ago

    I’ve passed here often but never had a chance to visit. Yesterday I decided to give it a shot. The restaurant isn’t much to look at from the outside but that doesn’t mean much. The food was amazing. I went with the baked clams for my appetizer. Which were very good. For my main I couldn’t decide between the tortellini bolognese or the penne vodka with shrimp. So I asked my waiter’s opinion & he suggested combining the two. So I took his advice & had tortellini vodka with shrimp. It was extremely delicious, the vodka sauce was especially creamy & both the shrimp & pasta were fresh. It was an extremely filling meal as well. On a side note you may want to avoid eating the pre meal bread with butter & save the bread for the excess sauce from your main. I usually prefer NY style cheesecakes but since they were serving a HOMEMADE ricotta cheesecake I had to take a slice to go. I couldn’t eat another bite after that amazing dinner. The restaurant is on the small side & can probably seat around 40 people. It has an old school vibe to it & the food is amazing. I had half of the slice of cheesecake for breakfast this morning. It was surprisingly delicious & moist (I often find Italian cheesecake to be dry). I would definitely recommend stopping here for dinner.

  • Bingna Z
    3 month ago

    Recommend to make an appointment in advance. Good place to hang out with friends and family.

  • Patricia Zangara
    3 month ago

    What a phenomenal experience! We went based on recommendations from TikTok. Small restaurant with a few tables, its cash only!! We did not think we would get seated, but Andy, I believe is the owner, he assured us that he would get us a table and told us to please wait and within 20 minutes we were seated!!! I’m so happy we stayed because the chicken Parm is the best I’ve ever had. You could cut it with a knife!! Its family style! Prices are reasonable.. go hungry.

  • Seow DeFino
    3 month ago

    Food is very good, the best Italian food in Brooklyn.

  • Jenny W
    3 month ago

    Very cozy and clean restaurant with nice ambiance! The staff were friendly and welcoming. We were seated right away and the gentleman who waited on us was very efficient. We were first served some bread and butter - the bread was one of the best I’ve had! Adding the butter to the bread made the bread taste even more heavenly. We ordered the ravioli and the chicken parm with a side of broccoli. The dishes were served in big portions and were delicious! They were big enough that we felt like we could have ordered one dish for 2 people. Whenever you get a chance to visit this restaurant, please remember to bring enough cash since it is a cash-only restaurant. Only found out after eating here that the restaurant is family-owned and has been around for decades. So glad we found this hidden gem!

  • Shay Sharopova
    4 month ago

    We changed the reservation time maybe that’s why we had to wait. Other than that the food was amazing! Everything seemed fresh and delicious. Loved the homemade balsamic glaze! The eggplant Parmesan was melting in my mouth lol. The shrimp was bomb, fried calamari was definitely a hit. Everything was very good. Hands down this place is one of the best authentic Italian places. Definitely must go places! Loved the Italian old school vibes.

Share Your Experience

Your Rating

Discover What Travelers Love About This Place

Real experiences, honest impressions, and insights shared by the Wherevi community to help you explore with confidence.